Canon software will require Login with Canon ID

I find it odd that my Canon ID and CPS membership are not synchronised, and that there is not a way to synchronise them. I always keep my CPS product list up to date, but my Canon ID product list I have neglected for a couple of years and it is way out of date.
 
Upvote 0
Just curious, don't most folks here already have a Canon account if and when they registered any Canon equipment? So all this hand wringing about Canon having your email, they probably already do and it means nothing.
As long as it is an option it's fine. Do you like an off-site storage for your products IDs, etc.? That's OK, as long as it is not mandatory. I registered mine just because here in Europe once it gave access to CPS - which had some advantages - now no longer.

But it's not just about "having your email"- you can create one for that - it's about being able to track users when the software is active. If a GPS enabled camera can phone home and send a unique user ID and its position, you can be tracked. Canon can use those that itself, or can even sell them - or at least give some kind of access to other companies willingly to pay for targeting. That's what mobile phone companies and their app developers are doing. Recently my banking app requested practically full access to my phone - being able to gather data about the app I have installed, the WiFi networks I connect to, etc. etc. in the name of "fraud prevention" - just that way they also collect a huge amount of data and positions they can use for commercial purposes as well....
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 2 users
Upvote 0
I use DPP for all my landscape photos as it is the only Raw editor that gives me true Canon color. I don't have an especially fast PC, and have no issues at all with speed or anything else.
I prefer in most cases the color and tone of the final images that DPP produces over LR, but I don't have the same positive experience with speed and workflow. There are just a few simple and common features in LR that DPP should pick up (even free Faststone Image Viewer has them). As for the speed, I do have a fast PC and GPU, but two operations are much slower compared to LR: updating of preview images (I have "Prioritize image quality" selected), and file export speed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Upvote 0
I opened Cannon Connect on my iPhone and tried to sign in with my MyCanon ID and password. It said the ID or password was incorrect. It gave me the option to create a new password and sent a link to my email. I filled it out and submitted it and if gave me an error screen.

So for now, I can neither create a Canon ID nor use the one I have for MyCanon. I could probably use a new email address and create a whole new profile, but since all of my Canon products are registered in MyCanon, that doesn't seem like a logical way to proceed.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
For those who have already registered a product or place an order on their website, it seems the only need is to retrieve password or initialise a new one... not a big deal. :D
Though at that point, the way account is working and managed on the different parts of their website is not completely clear... still Canon ID is definetely the same as my old account (and I'm no pro).

And of course, they allow to delete your already existing "Canon ID"/account at any time.

I'll add that since I have an account (2018), I've not really been spammed by them. Nothing invasive.
 
Upvote 0
And thank goodness their software is terrible enough that you don't need it in terms of DPP anyway. I have to say their software development is quite garbage, that app is in a most laughable state and has some of the most ancient ridiculous UI conventions from the stone era.
You would be surprised how many people defend the shoddy state of Canon’s DPP because “it’s free”.

I don’t expect a lightroom replacement, but with the cost of their bodies and lenses, I do expect software that is modern and easy to use. After all, a number of their lenses require digital correction and DPP is the only software that can do this with manufacturer derived information. Will we require a subscription to that?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Upvote 0
NVIDIA did something similar for a couple of years then scrapped it earlier this year. I don't think it will be a wise move for Canon to go down the same path just to be able to use their terribly optimized software. Personally I dropped it in favor of DXO a while back because of the frustrating user experience.
 
Upvote 0
This is Big Brother tactics launching the thin end of the wedge. To pay thousands of dollars for a camera then be told "oh you have to have an account against your will to use the software to get the most out of your camera" flies in the face of consumer rights. Indeed I am fairly sure this would be in breach of current Australian Consumer Laws where some companies have already been prosecuted for only offering full length warranties to customer who "registered" (a.k.a. surrended heaps of personal details about themselves to go onto a database they have no control of) and customers who refused to register their purchase within some time frame after buying it only got a shortened warranty. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) ruled that is restriction of consumer rights. They have also prosecuted several big retailers for misleadingly offering cost-extra extended warranties past the basic, e.g. a fridge may come with a manufacturers warranty of 1 year and the retailer offers an additional 4 years for a fee, but in Australia the ACCC ruled nobody buys a fridge expecting it to fail after 12 months so if it dies 2 or 3 years after purchase, you are still entitled to full warranty repairs or replacement, and manufacturers warranty statements cannot contravene the basic consumer rights, in the same way as if a store has a sign at the entry saying it is a condition of entry that all bags be presented for searching at the exit, that cannot override common law which says only Police and Customs have the right to search a person. I would personally lodge a formal complaint to ACCC if Canon tries this stunt in Australia as others will also no doubt do. Hopefully the EU will jump all over this. It's a massive insult to democracy to be told you have to create an account (which I bet requires at least an e-mail address to spam you) just to use the product you have bought. I know in some countries you can only play DVD's or blu-rays that match the local region code but down under any machine must have the ability to override region codes and play DVD's and blu-rays sourced from any region in the world. The fact some players bury that unlock function deep in hidden menus indicates they build the products for the world markets and only unlock what they have to to comply with local laws. Canon are really pushing their luck with this one. Personally I don't give a fat rat's clacker about DPP as it is slow and clunky at the best of times even on my i9 with 64GB DDR-5 RAM, but if the EOS Utility requires a login for me to download images from my camera, game on moll.
Yeah, nah.. this isn’t about extended warranty.
The accc hasn’t had a problem for drones and action cams needing activation via an app and you won’t get your dji drone off the ground without an account… I get the need for the latter but action cams??
We will see the detail later but it isn’t justified at this time given the software available (excluding the VR stuff).
It might avoid the need to send back the body if you want the portrait grid option though
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Upvote 0
Big and small businesses are willing to harass their customers to squeeze out even tiny amounts of extra profit. They figure we already have 100 usernames and passwords to deal with, what is one more? As a dad with elementary kids, I do my best to avoid the seemingly endless apps which teachers and school-event organizers use to communicate with us. Many of these are invasive, asking for personal information about us and our kids.

At this point, I think any idea of some massive customer rebellion is just a dream.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
At this point, I think any idea of some massive customer rebellion is just a dream.
As Shoshana Zuboff wrote (in her The Age of Surveillance Capitalism), the rebellion of small users groups can't achieve much. It would require a stronger movement able to influence "decision makers" - but I'm afraid the wind is blowing in the opposite direction (the same where money flows). Generative AI is also data voracious, thereby all sources will be exploited - until the bubble bursts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Upvote 0